° empty

Not voting for Maddux indefensible

Greg Maddux was not a unanimous hall of famer, which makes about as much sense as a waterproof towel.

I’ve always said the litmus test for whether a player should make the Baseball Hall of Fame goes something like this: If you’re having to ask whether or not a player should make the hall of fame, that tells you he’s not a hall of famer.

With Maddux, an emphatic “yes” should jump out of your mouth before you even finish that question.

Maddux carries a career earned-run average of 3.16, a number that would likely be even lower had he not pitched into his 40s. He has 355 wins, 3,371 strikeouts and was a four-time NL Cy Young Award winner. He was also a member of the 1995 Atlanta Braves World Series championship team.

Maddux didn’t overpower anyone but instead relied on exceptional command and mechanics to get hitters out. He was also known for his ability to seemingly outsmart hitters. Hall of famer Wade Boggs once said this about Maddux: “It seems like he’s inside you’re mind with you. When he knows you’re not going to swing, he throws a straight one. He sees into the future. It’s like he has a crystal ball hidden inside his glove.”

Put simply, the man was a professor, and he didn’t give out A’s — or B’s, for that matter. Probably not even C’s.

This past week, Maddux was named a first-ballot hall of famer, securing 97.19 percent of the votes. In other words, 16 voters didn’t think Maddux was hall-of-fame-worthy.

Considering that Maddux is likely one of the top 10 pitchers to ever play the game, not voting him into the hall of fame is indefensible.

One voter, MLB.com writer Ken Gurnick, said he didn’t vote for any “steroid-era player” because he “didn’t know who did and who didn’t” use performance-enhancing drugs.

With all due respect, that’s a ponderous attitude to take. Even if you don’t want to include steroid users, the fact is, there were no rumors, no whispers, no anything surrounding Maddux with regard to PEDs. There is no justifiable reason not to vote for him — none.

One prevailing thought among voters is there should never be anyone who is a unanimous hall of famer, because it’s never happened before. No doubt that line of thinking was the prevailing thought for at least some of the 16 voters who left Maddux off their list.

So, tradition for the sake of tradition. If there was anyone deserving of a unanimous selection, it’s Greg Maddux. Mariano Rivera is also deserving, but if Maddux wasn’t a unanimous choice, I doubt Rivera will be when he’s finally eligible.

Maddux is in the hall, which is the most important thing. But it would have been fitting for someone who was such a gem when it came to the art of pitching to be baseball’s first unanimous selection. Instead, at least one writer looking to make a statement and others likely not wanting to “buck a trend” prevented that.

I’m more likely to figure out Maddux’s train of thought on the mound than I am to understand that kind of logic.

News

CPSO rules missing person case homicide

News

Adams County supervisors to review ambulance proposals Wednesday

News

Burnley Cook to withdraw from Ward 6 alderman race

News

Viewfinder: Cathedral student starts local health fair

News

Man arrested for Magnolia Grill burglary

News

Photo gallery: Jewish community celebrates Passover with Seder dinner

News

NASD graduation rate up, but still lags behind state average

News

The Dart: Vidalia man studies, takes care of family, too

News

Natchez Early College Academy Fun Day to help raise money for trip to Washington, D.C.

News

Parent University set for Thursday

News

Sunday focus: Voters to determine a quarter million in salaries May 10

News

Concordia Parish Sheriff’s Office investigates body found in Monterey

News

County seeking ambulance proposals

News

‘Suzi’s Girls’ remember lasting legacy left by coach

News

Natchez man killed in Ferriday wreck Friday night

News

Photo gallery: The bluff has gone to the DockDogs

News

Tactics in case surrounding alleged attack of parish DA questioned

News

Student charged in verbal assault of teacher

News

City back in court to determine damages in Roundstone case

News

Report: Cuts put school district $1.5M short

News

Faith and Family: R.V.I.C.S. helps Children’s Home

News

Photo gallery: Chalk artist inspired by God creates artwork at First Baptist Church

News

Man previously arrested on rape charges, charged with another sex crime

News

Natchez-Adams School District to pay $127K to former principal