‘We have earned it’: Natchez-Adams School District report card jumps from D to B grade
Published 11:00 am Tuesday, September 27, 2022
NATCHEZ — Natchez-Adams School District’s report card from the Mississippi Department of Education shows improvement by two letter grades—from D to B—from the last time grades were issued pre-pandemic, according to preliminary results released by the Mississippi Department of Education on Tuesday.
The grade will become official when the Mississippi State Board of Education approves accountability grades Thursday, Sept. 29, for the 2021-22 school year. Mississippi’s schools and districts are graded on an A-F scale. Due to the pandemic, this is the first year new grades have been issued since 2019.
Individually, almost all schools in Natchez-Adams School District show improvement in their accountability grade.
Email newsletter signup
McLaurin Elementary improved from a B to an A. Joseph L. Frazier Elementary improved by two letter grades, from a D in 2018-19 to a B. Susie B. West, Morgantown Middle, Natchez High School, and Natchez Freshman Academy all improved from a D to a C. Robert Lewis Magnet School maintained a C grade from the 2018-19 school year.
The district has shown steady improvement since 2015 when it had an F grade.
“Success doesn’t just happen. It has to be earned. Well, we have earned it,” Deputy Superintendent Zandra McDonald-Green said.
School board members shared their congratulations with administrators, teachers, students and their families.
“We have achieved something that I didn’t anticipate happening this soon. This is not only good for the students. It’s also good for our community,” board member Phillip West said. He added the students have overcome more challenges than the pandemic alone. The demographic makeup of the district and poverty has always been a challenge in the community, he said. “God has given all of our children the talent to be something better than they anticipate they can be.”
Elected leaders and community members joined Natchez Adams School District officials in a celebration meeting on Tuesday as the grades were announced. Adams County Board of Supervisors President Wes Middleton congratulated the school board and administrators “but most of all the students” for their hard work, he said.
“To say that we in Natchez are excelling with all of the challenges is truly remarkable,” Natchez Mayor Dan Gibson said.
Adams County Sheriff Travis Patten agreed.
“You all have taken on one heck of a fight through the years,” he said. “You have been drug through the mud by the public, parents and everything but you all have stood firm in what you believe and stayed invested in the kids. This is the result of that.”
School board president Amos James said the district worked hard to achieve a B grade and would have to work even harder to keep it.
“I want to thank the community for the good and the bad comments because the bad comments are what kept us on our toes,” he said.
Overall, MDE officials say grades appear to have improved statewide, making a bounce back to pre-pandemic levels. The grades reflect how student achievement has improved after declining during the early part of the pandemic.
Neighboring Jefferson County School District also improved by two grades from an F to a C, MDE results show. Claiborne County School District improved from an F to a B. Franklin County school district went down a letter grade from a B to a C. Wilkinson and Amite County school districts both maintained an F grade.
The SBE set a goal in 2016 that all schools and districts be rated C or higher. From 2016 to 2019, the percentage of schools meeting this goal rose from 62.4% to 73.5%. The percentage of districts meeting the goal has increased from 62.2% to 69.7%. Over the same period, the number of schools and districts earning an A more than doubled, with A-rated schools jumping from 88 to 196, and A-rated districts increasing from 14 to 31.
State officials advise caution when interpreting score changes between the 2018-19 and 2021-22 school years. In particular, substantial shifts in performance may be temporarily influenced by factors associated with pandemic disruptions. The 2021-22 school and district grades were impacted by key factors involving student achievement decline in 2020-21, testing waivers and one-year adjustments to the accountability system.
“The pandemic not only disrupted teaching and learning; it also impacted the state’s accountability system that evaluates the effectiveness of schools and districts,” said Dr. Kim Benton, state superintendent of education, interim. “While we are encouraged by the tremendous growth, it is especially important this year to look at all the components that make up each school and district grade to get a complete picture of student growth and achievement.”
Statewide student assessment data make up a large part of accountability grades. In 2021-22, the overall percentage of students scoring proficient and advanced mostly returned to pre-pandemic rates; however, the percentage of students scoring in the bottom two achievement levels increased. The state assessment system has five levels, minimal, basic, passing, proficient and advanced.
The calculation of the state’s A-F accountability grades relies heavily on the amount of progress students make in English Language Arts (ELA) and Mathematics from one year to the next, particularly the lowest performing 25% of students. In addition, the passing requirements for high school Algebra I, English II, Biology and U.S. History assessments were waived in 2020-21, which will affect the graduation rate until all students who tested under the waivers graduate.
Dr. Chris Domaleski, associate director of the National Center for the Improvement of Educational Assessment and chair of the Mississippi Department of Education Technical Advisory Committee, said the 2021-22 grades should always be viewed in the context of the pandemic.
“Schooling has been disrupted for more than two years, which affected the way students learned and were assessed,” Domaleski said. “However, the department responded to these disruptions by making appropriate adjustments to the accountability system while maintaining consistency where possible. This enables the state to continue to provide valuable information about school and district performance in 2021-2022.”
Federal law requires all states to assess students annually in ELA and Mathematics in grades 3-8 and once during high school. Mississippi law requires schools and districts to earn annual A-F grades based on student performance and growth.
Mississippi’s accountability system includes the following components:
- Student proficiency and growth rates in ELA and Mathematics in grades 3-8
- Growth of the lowest performing 25% of students in ELA and Mathematics
- Science proficiency in grades 5 and 8
- English Learner progress toward becoming proficient in the English language
- Performance on the ACT and high school Algebra I, English II, Biology and U.S. History assessments
- Student participation and performance in advanced coursework such as Advanced Placement and dual credit/dual enrollment courses
- Four-year graduation rate
The SBE temporarily adjusted the statewide accountability system in 2021-22 to calculate A-F grades and determine federally required school improvement designations. Adjustments were needed because the cancellation of assessments in spring 2020 resulted in some students lacking scores to calculate growth.
The U.S. Department of Education (USED) granted waivers to states from federal accountability requirements for the 2019-20 and 2020-21 school years because the pandemic disrupted schooling and state assessments. The USED required all states to resume their accountability systems and identification of schools for support and improvement for the 2021-22 school year but allowed states to request a one-year addendum plan to adjust for missing data.
The MDE worked closely with the state’s Accountability Task Force, Technical Advisory Committee and the Center for Assessment to review and analyze assessment data to ensure the addendum proposal was technically sound and presented an accurate picture of the academic performance of Mississippi students.
The pandemic broke the comparability of pre-pandemic progress to the 2021-22 grades.
“After the early setbacks of the pandemic, Mississippi educators provided an enormous amount of support to help students recover from the interruptions to teaching and learning,” Dr. Benton said. “I am confident this work will continue to close achievement gaps and ensure all students graduate from high school prepared for success in college and the workforce.”